Monthly Mystery Packs [Premium]

Packs: 3
Sale price$36.00


The premium version of this product means we'll be picking from older sets with increased rarity and higher value cards - as well as GUARANTEEING a Extra Spicy Pack from the Extra Spice set list.  Our Extra Spicy set list are the most popular sets printed in Magic's history, as well as some of the most valuable. 

With the three pack option, we are sending out AT LEAST 1 Extra Spice pack.

With the six pack option, we are sending out AT LEAST 2 Extra Spice packs.

With the nine pack option, we are sending out AT LEAST 3 Extra Spice packs.

ALL orders have a 6% chance to hit and roll from the Phantom Pack list [see below]

Here is our current list of potential sets for packs:

EXTRA SPICE SET LIST [Guaranteed to be in every purchase]: 

  • Double Masters 2022 *NEW*
  • [Special Edition] Commander Collection: Green
  • [Special Edition] Planechase Anthology
  • Masters 2013
  • Masters 2015
  • Masters 2017
  • Ultimate Masters
  • Eternal Masters
  • Double Masters [Draft/VIP]
  • Double Masters 2022 [Draft/Collectors]
  • Masters 25
  • Modern Horizons 1
  • Modern Horizons 2 Set
  • Kaladesh
  • Morningtide
  • Shards of Alara
  • Coldsnap
  • Torment 
  • Nemesis
  • New Phyrexia
  • Double Feature
  • Mirrodin Besieged 
  • Collector Packs [MH2 - CL - IKO - NEO - AFR - KHM - DMU *UPCOMING]

PHANTOM PACKS [Rare: .05% - 4%]: 

  • Revised [0.05%]
  • Onslaught
  • 7th Edition
  • 4th Edition
  • The Dark
  • Rise of the Eldrazi
  • Shards of Alara
  • Torment
  • Darksteel
  • Saviors of Kamigawa
  • Worldwake
  • Shadowmoor


  • Battlebond
  • Amonkhet
  • Aether Revolt
  • Battle for Zendikar
  • Oath of Gatewatch
  • Conspiracy
  • Eldritch Moon
  • Time Spiral Remastered
  • Double Feature
  • Dominaria
  • Gatecrash
  • Shadows over Innistrad
  • Rivals of Ixalan
  • Return to Ravnica
  • Ixalan
  • Ravnica Allegiance
  • Guilds of Ravnica 
  • War of the Spark
  • Throne of Eldraine
  • Hour of Devastation
  • Fate Reforged
  • Born of the Gods
  • Jumpstart
  • Theros
  • Journey into Nyx
  • Commander Legends



The sets listed are curated monthly - we take out the least popular sets and let customers vote on what sets they want to see: Have a set you like that isn't on the list? Send us an email!

Some sets appear on more than one list, therefore duplication is possible. Add disliked sets to your order notes so a re-roll can take place if they're won.

You may also like

Recently viewed

Customer Reviews

Based on 249 reviews
Christopher Whitney
A ton of fun!

Trying to pick out card packs can be pretty rough sometimes since there are so many possible pulls depending on each set. This is makes picking packs infinitely easier and is incredibly fun to open with friends.

Quinton Pererson

Monthly Mystery Packs [Premium]

Tyler Ball
Monthly Premium Packs

I would really like to see more of a variety... any chance of getting more collector booster or vintage boosters? I pay for the premium monthly packs and was hoping to get less repeats.

Thanks for the review and critic Tyler,

Your comment has been passed on to the team. We do attempt to limit duplication or repeats, but with how the randomizer and weight system works it is possible to see duplication in certain slots if orders are processed on a weekly basis

We'll look into negating this internally with improvements to our system with the upcoming winter set list changes

Mystery MTG

Fun for a lark

I can’t resist a mystery crate and I really enjoyed seeing what I got and opening them but I think that’s where a lot of the value in these is. I got two packs from the extra spicy list instead of the minimum one and probably still could have bought the individual packs for less than the price of the crate. Overall still happy but definitely not something I’d get recurring.

Hey Ben,

While RNG is a foundation for this crate (meaning your value range will be all over the place above our min value guarantee) we have to emphasis the importance of these packs coming from sealed boxes from (typically) first wave releases. We partner with some of the biggest companies in the space, distributors, and WOTC to get verified sealed product so you never have to worry about tampered with/resealed/weighed items. AKA: When you order the cheapest pack of AVR on TCG Player (where people will typically reference price) it has likely been weighed to see if a foil is in the pack, if it isn't, the seller lists it for a cheaper price and the buyer get's screwed on what they can pull.

While we can't match lowest listings, your chance at hitting amazing pulls and foils from older and newer packs are the highest when getting your packs from us. They're cracked from sealed boxes, from sealed cases, from distributors and verified partners.

That's where the real value comes from - and even with that in mind, we still send out amazing mixes of packs, with some being over 5x purchase price and if you're'll see some phantom packs that blow your mind!

We are also editing the Extra Spicy list to get rid of duplicants and some of the less popular packs.

Dan Rich
New list is flawed.

Fun product. But with the new list there are packs that are both spicy and extra spicy. If I’m not mistaken this would make them more common then other spicy packs. So how can they be “extra spicy”? Felt like I was getting shorted “extra spicy” packs.

Hey Dan,

We appreciate your feedback. We've simmered over this topic as a team, and have agreed to get rid of packs that exist on multiple tiers. We'll also be re-working the list a bit!

We appreciate you and your continued patronage of our business - feel free to contact us directly for any other concerns at or message us directly on our discord!